Justia Mississippi Supreme Court Opinion Summaries

by
An individual suffering from chronic illness and mental impairment was admitted to a nursing facility, where his primary physician later determined that he lacked capacity to make healthcare decisions. The facility required appointment of a surrogate, and the patient’s brother assumed the role by signing the relevant forms and an arbitration agreement on the patient’s behalf. The surrogate-appointment paperwork erroneously identified the brother as an “adult child” rather than a sibling. Years later, the patient was severely burned in an incident involving a cigarette lighter and an oxygen tank, prompting a lawsuit alleging inadequate care by the facility.The United States District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, Northern Division, was presented with the facility’s motion to compel arbitration based on the agreement signed by the brother. The patient, through his guardian, opposed this, arguing that under Mississippi law, the patient’s adult son had higher statutory priority to serve as surrogate and was reasonably available, so the brother lacked authority to bind the patient to arbitration. The district court agreed, finding that the statute required healthcare providers to confirm the unavailability of higher-priority family members before accepting decisions from those with lower priority, and denied the motion to compel arbitration. The facility appealed.The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit certified to the Supreme Court of Mississippi the question of whether the Uniform Health-Care Decisions Act requires providers, in the absence of a designated surrogate, to identify and ensure that no higher-priority family member is reasonably available before relying on a lower-priority member’s healthcare decision. The Supreme Court of Mississippi held that the statute does impose this requirement, thus obligating healthcare providers to confirm the unavailability of higher-priority surrogates before accepting healthcare decisions from lower-priority family members. The court answered the certified question in the affirmative. View "Stanford v. Brandon Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, L.L.C." on Justia Law

by
Harvey Lott, an employee of PriorityOne Bank, contracted with JSC-Americanzil Construction, LLC to build his home and encouraged the contractor to obtain a construction loan from his employer. Dissatisfied with the construction, Lott sued JSC, and JSC counterclaimed, alleging Lott improperly pressured them into a bank loan and raised several contract-related claims. The parties settled, executing a release that broadly discharged all claims between them, including any against PriorityOne Bank relating to the home construction and financing.Subsequently, Jason Ray Temple and his wife, who had also hired JSC to build their home and financed it through PriorityOne Bank, sued JSC and PriorityOne for defects in their home. JSC filed a cross-complaint against PriorityOne Bank in this new lawsuit, raising claims similar to those previously settled. PriorityOne Bank moved to dismiss or for summary judgment, arguing that the earlier settlement barred these claims. Judge Matthew Sullivan of the Covington County Circuit Court initially dismissed the cross-complaint but later recused himself. Judge Stanley Sorey reinstated the cross-complaint and denied PriorityOne Bank’s renewed motion to dismiss or for summary judgment, prompting this interlocutory appeal.The Supreme Court of Mississippi determined that the release from the prior settlement was clear and unambiguous, expressly naming and protecting PriorityOne Bank as a third-party beneficiary from claims related to the Lott home construction and its financing. The Court held that the cross-complaint in the Temple lawsuit raised only issues already addressed and settled in the previous litigation. Finding no genuine issue of material fact, the Supreme Court of Mississippi reversed the circuit court’s order, rendered summary judgment in favor of PriorityOne Bank, and remanded the case for further proceedings. View "PriorityOne Bank v. JSC-Americanzil Construction, LLC" on Justia Law

by
A city attorney entered into a retainer agreement with a municipal board, serving as an independent contractor at the board’s pleasure, with the agreement permitting termination at will, with or without cause. Several months into the engagement, disputes arose regarding the attorney’s invoices and billing practices. The board discussed these concerns at various meetings and, at a special-called meeting, voted to terminate the attorney’s retainer agreement. The agenda for this meeting listed “Attorney Bills?” but did not explicitly mention termination of the attorney’s contract. The attorney did not attend the meeting and received notice of his termination the following day.After his termination, the attorney appealed to the Sunflower County Circuit Court under Mississippi Code Section 11-51-75, arguing that the meeting was not lawfully noticed for the business transacted, specifically the termination of his contract, and that he was denied due process. The City responded that the attorney was an at-will contractor with no property interest requiring due process and that the board acted within its legal authority. The circuit court found that the attorney had standing and had timely appealed but held that the board’s decision was not arbitrary, capricious, discriminatory, or illegal, and that as an at-will contractor, the attorney was owed no hearing or due process protections.On appeal, the Supreme Court of Mississippi held that while the board could terminate the attorney at will and owed no hearing, the termination action taken at the special-called meeting was void because the written call for the meeting did not distinctly specify the subject of terminating the city attorney, as required by statute and city ordinance. The court accepted the City’s failure to file a brief as a confession of error, reversed the circuit court’s order, set aside the termination, and remanded the case for further proceedings consistent with its opinion. The court denied the attorney’s requests for additional relief. View "Hopson v. City of Indianola, Mississippi" on Justia Law

by
Linda Fay Campbell underwent kidney surgery at St. Dominic-Jackson Memorial Hospital, during which her colon was unintentionally perforated. Campbell subsequently required additional surgery by Dr. Jeffery Glover to address the perforation. Later, a surgical sponge was discovered in Campbell’s abdomen from the prior surgery, requiring yet another operation by Dr. Glover. Campbell initially filed a medical-negligence personal injury suit against Dr. Tanaka, Dr. Glover, and St. Dominic. She passed away while the suit was pending, and her estate and wrongful death beneficiaries sought to pursue claims related to her death and pre-death injuries.After Campbell’s death, her attorneys filed a suggestion of death and indicated an amended complaint would be filed on behalf of her estate and wrongful death beneficiaries. However, the motion to substitute parties was not timely under Mississippi Rule of Civil Procedure 25. The parties agreed to dismiss Dr. Tanaka with prejudice and later dismissed the original suit without prejudice, preserving claims for wrongful death. Torrie Campbell Knight, as administratrix, then filed a new complaint alleging wrongful death against Dr. Glover and others. As discovery progressed, St. Dominic and Dr. Tanaka were dismissed, leaving Dr. Glover as the sole defendant. Dr. Glover moved for summary judgment, arguing that no act or omission by him proximately caused Campbell’s death and that any personal injury claims were barred.The Supreme Court of Mississippi reviewed whether the wrongful death complaint adequately pled a separate personal-injury-survival claim. The Court held that the complaint only asserted a wrongful death claim under the wrongful death statute and did not include a distinct personal-injury-survival claim. Therefore, the Court found summary judgment for Dr. Glover was proper, reversed the Court of Appeals’ decision, reinstated, and affirmed the judgment of the Circuit Court of the First Judicial District of Hinds County. View "Knight v. Glover" on Justia Law

by
Derek and Keisha Hall hired Jose Silva to construct their new home and financed the project through Priority One Bank, where Harvey Lott served as the loan officer. The Halls later discovered construction defects and alleged that Silva, Lott, and the bank engaged in a secret arrangement for personal profit, including unauthorized loan disbursements and a failure to conduct proper inspections. The Halls also claimed Silva lacked a contractor’s license and that the relationship between Silva and Lott involved improper payments. Both Lott and the bank denied these allegations, asserting that bank inspections were for their own benefit and that loan advances sometimes occurred before work was completed, in line with their agreement.The Halls brought several claims against the bank, Lott, and Silva in the Jefferson Davis County Circuit Court, including breach of contract, fraud, and conspiracy. In response, the bank and Lott sought summary judgment, but the circuit court denied their motion, finding that genuine issues of material fact remained. Subsequently, the Halls moved to strike a provision in the loan agreement, arguing it was unconscionable and deprived them of legal remedies. The circuit court granted this motion, holding the provision was void, invalid, and unconscionable.The Supreme Court of Mississippi reviewed the case on interlocutory appeal. It held that the Halls’ “Motion to Strike Contract Provision” was not an appropriate procedural vehicle to challenge the enforceability of a contract provision, as motions to strike under Mississippi Rule of Civil Procedure 12(f) are limited to pleadings, not contract clauses. The court reversed the circuit court’s order striking the provision and remanded the case for further proceedings, directing that any challenge to the provision’s enforceability must follow the proper procedures for dispositive motions. View "Priority One Bank v. Hall" on Justia Law

by
Green Cross of MS, LLC applied for a medical cannabis dispensary license for a location in Oxford, Mississippi. The Mississippi Medical Cannabis Act prohibits dispensaries from operating within one thousand feet of schools, churches, or childcare facilities unless certain waivers are obtained, and only for locations between five hundred and one thousand feet from these entities. Green Cross obtained a waiver from a nearby childcare facility and verified, through a survey and public records, that no church owned property within the restricted area. However, the Alcoholic Beverage Control division of the Mississippi Department of Revenue discovered that Wellspring Church was operating services within ninety-nine feet of the proposed dispensary, although the church did not own the property.After ABC denied the license application due to proximity to Wellspring Church, it refunded Green Cross’s $25,000 annual license fee but not the $15,000 application fee. Green Cross appealed to the Panola County Circuit Court, arguing that the church did not qualify under the Act’s definition since it lacked a property interest. The circuit court affirmed the denial of the license but ordered ABC to refund the application fee, reasoning that not doing so in these circumstances would be arbitrary.The Supreme Court of Mississippi reviewed both appeals. The Court affirmed the circuit court’s decision to uphold the denial of the dispensary license, holding that the Act does not require a church to own the property for the restriction to apply. However, it reversed the circuit court’s order requiring ABC to refund the application fee, concluding that the Act only allows refunds in cases where a denial is based on proximity to another dispensary and not for proximity to churches. The Court’s disposition was reversed on direct appeal and affirmed on cross-appeal. View "Mississippi Alcoholic Beverage Control v. Green Cross of MS, LLC" on Justia Law

by
A tenant at an apartment complex sustained a knee injury while attempting to avoid a water puddle on a sidewalk between her apartment building and the parking lot during a rainstorm at night. The sidewalk had a longstanding issue with water, mud, and debris collecting in a depressed section due to a disconnected downspout and sidewalk deterioration. The tenant, who had a history of knee problems, stepped off the sidewalk to avoid the puddle and slipped on a concealed jagged edge, aggravating her knee. She later underwent surgery and filed suit against the apartment management, alleging negligent maintenance of the premises.The case was tried in the Circuit Court of Hinds County, Mississippi. The plaintiff presented expert testimony from Kenneth Goodrum, who was designated as a premises safety expert. Park Wind, the defendant, objected to Goodrum’s qualifications and methodology, arguing he lacked sufficient experience and that his approach was not reliable under the Mississippi Rules of Evidence. The trial court denied these objections, allowed Goodrum to testify as an expert, and the jury found in favor of the plaintiff. The defendant’s post-trial motion to exclude Goodrum’s testimony and for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, a new trial, or remittitur was denied without analysis.On appeal, the Supreme Court of Mississippi found that the trial court had abused its discretion by qualifying Goodrum as an expert. The court held that Goodrum did not possess the necessary knowledge, skill, experience, or education in premises safety and that his methodology was not sufficiently scientific or specialized to aid the jury. The Supreme Court determined that this error was prejudicial and not harmless. Accordingly, it reversed the judgment of the circuit court and remanded the case for a new trial. View "Park Wind Apartments, LLC v. Mayze" on Justia Law

Posted in: Personal Injury
by
A man was found inside a residence in Woodville, Mississippi, by a woman who recognized him as someone she had known since childhood. His behavior was described as markedly different and concerning. He was reportedly armed with multiple firearms and made threats toward those present in the house. The woman and others eventually left the residence and alerted law enforcement to his presence and the fact that he was armed. When law enforcement, including two police chiefs, arrived and attempted to apprehend him, the man exited the house and fired two shots in the direction of the officers. One officer initially believed he had been struck, but it was determined he was hit by debris. The man fled and was apprehended approximately a week later.The Circuit Court of Wilkinson County held a jury trial, where the jury found the defendant guilty of aggravated assault on a law-enforcement officer under Mississippi law. He was sentenced to thirty years in prison. On appeal, he argued that the jury was not properly instructed on the essential elements of the offense and that the verdict was contrary to the overwhelming weight of the evidence because no physical or forensic evidence linked him to the shooting.The Supreme Court of Mississippi reviewed the appeal. It held that the supplemented record showed the jury was properly instructed on all essential elements of aggravated assault on a law-enforcement officer, in accordance with statutory requirements. The court also found that credible testimonial evidence from eyewitnesses supported the verdict, and that it was not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence. The Supreme Court of Mississippi affirmed the conviction and sentence. View "Carr v. State of Mississippi" on Justia Law

Posted in: Criminal Law
by
A subcontractor performed fabrication and machining services for a general contractor on a filtration plant project. The arrangement included a provision that the subcontractor would be paid only after the general contractor received payment from the owner. When payment to the subcontractor ceased due to a dispute between the general contractor and the owner, the subcontractor filed two construction liens against the property to secure payment, attaching multiple invoices to each lien. The liens themselves did not state the date the claim was due, but included invoices bearing various dates.After the subcontractor filed suit to enforce the liens and for other related claims, the owner removed the case to the United States District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi. The owner moved to dismiss, arguing that the liens were invalid because they did not “specify the date the claim was due” as required by Mississippi Code Section 85-7-405(1)(b). The district court agreed, finding that neither the liens nor the attached invoices clearly identified the last date labor, services, or materials were supplied, and dismissed the complaint with prejudice. The subcontractor appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.The Fifth Circuit found no clear controlling Mississippi precedent on whether attaching invoices with dates, but without clear explanation of what those dates represent, satisfies the statutory requirement. It certified the question to the Supreme Court of Mississippi. The Supreme Court of Mississippi held that simply attaching invoices with dates that do not plainly indicate the last date labor, services, or materials were supplied does not satisfy the requirement that an enforceable lien “specify the date the claim was due” under Section 85-7-405(1)(b). The certified question was answered in the negative. View "Cuevas Machine Company, Inc. v. Calgon Carbon Corporation" on Justia Law

by
A woman, Emily, had been under a conservatorship granted to her mother in 2012 due to mental incapacity and remained under that conservatorship, which was never formally terminated. Emily became a mother of four children. In early 2023, after concerns about the care and living situation of her youngest child, Zane, the Prentiss County Department of Child Protection Services (CPS) intervened. Zane was removed from Emily's custody and placed in foster care following an emergency order. Emily was given a reunification service plan, but failed to comply with its requirements, including obtaining stable housing and addressing drug use. Over the next two years, Emily struggled with housing, employment, and substance abuse, while Zane remained in foster care and developed a bond with his foster family.The Prentiss County Youth Court adjudicated Zane as a neglected child in April 2023, though Emily’s conservator, Lisa, was not served with process or present at the adjudication. Both Emily and Lisa participated in later proceedings. No appeal was taken from the adjudication or disposition orders. In August 2024, a permanency review led to a plan for Zane's adoption. Subsequently, the Prentiss County Chancery Court heard a petition to terminate parental rights. Carter, the father, voluntarily surrendered his rights. At the termination hearing, Emily argued that the underlying adjudication was void due to lack of service on her conservator, but the chancellor found this objection had been waived due to ongoing participation in the proceedings without timely objection or appeal.The Supreme Court of Mississippi reviewed whether the youth court had personal jurisdiction over Emily and whether the chancellor erred in terminating her parental rights. The court held that any deficiency in service was waived by the parties’ participation and failure to timely object. The court also found that substantial evidence supported termination of Emily’s parental rights under statutory grounds, including desertion and substantial erosion of the parent-child relationship. The judgment of the chancery court was affirmed. View "E.K.W. v. Prentiss County Department of Child Protection Services" on Justia Law